Legal Analysis of Children as Victims of
Sexual Violence
����������������������������������
Rini Angriani, Syawal Abdulajid, Suwarti
Postgraduate
Program at Khairun University, Ternate, Indonesia
Email: [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected]
|
ARTICLE
INFO |
ABSTRACT |
|
Date received: 2 Januari 2023 Date revised: 10 Februari 2023 Date accepted: 20 Maret 2023 |
This study aims to analyze the factors that
cause children to become victims of sexual violence committed by perpetrators
of crimes and obstacles in providing legal protection for children as victims
of sexual violence. The applied research method is normative legal research,
leading to the identification of legal rules, principles, and doctrines in
response to the legal problems faced. The scientific approach in this study
is based on the disciplines and working principles of normative legal
science, focusing on the analysis of law itself. The results of this study
show that legal protection measures provided for victims of underage sexual
relations and rape in the criminal justice system are carried out through
preventive and repressive approaches, both by the community and the
government (through law enforcement officials), such as providing protection/supervision
from various threats that can endanger the lives of victims, providing
adequate medical and legal assistance, examination and judicial process. This
research has significant implications in identifying the triggering factors
of sexual violence against children and challenges in their legal protection.
The normative legal research approach not only provides insight into relevant
legal aspects, but also explores legal principles and doctrines to formulate solutions to these problems. |
|
Keywords: Child Victims, Sexual
Violence. |
INTRODUCTION
Children as creatures of God Almighty have basic
rights like other human beings, so no human or other party can take away these
rights. In the life of the nation and state, children are the future of the
nation and the next generation of the nation's ideals so that every child has
the right to survival, growth and development, participation and is entitled to
protection from acts of violence and discrimination as well as civil rights and
freedoms.(Tjahjanto, 2008).
The position of children in society is very
vulnerable considering their physical and mental conditions that are not yet
strong and mature. The number of cases of decency crimes lately actually places
children who are most often involved in these crimes, as perpetrators or
victims. A proper understanding of children's rights is clearly very important
and the main thing to do considering that children have all the hopes of the
Indonesian nation. Thus, it can be understood that children are a form of
investment which is an indicator of the success of a nation in carrying out
development. The success of child development will determine the quality of
human resources in the future(Widodo, 2016). Article 28 B paragraph (2) of the 1945
Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia (hereinafter abbreviated as the 1945
Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia) reads that (Sugiyantica, 2014):
Children have a strategic role and the state
guarantees the rights of every child to survival, growth and development as
well as protection from violence and discrimination. Therefore, the best
interests of children should be lived as the best interests for the survival of
mankind.
�� The
presence of Law Number 35 of 2014 concerning Child Protection has provided the
widest opportunity for a child to grow and develop optimally both physically
and mentally so that an ideal generation will be created. Therefore, if there
is sexual violence against children, of course this action is a form of child abuse.
If a child becomes a victim of crime, then for
legal protection, of course, more attention must be paid because children are
the next generation of the nation. For crimes of sexual violence experienced by
child victims, it certainly has a traumatic effect or a deep bad memory on the
child, this affects the behavior, lifestyle and behavior of the child in the
future. Thus, the increasing number of cases of sexual violence against
children proves that this problem is not just an ordinary problem. However, it
is a serious problem that must be addressed by the government.
The definition of sexual violence is often
confused. Whether or not there is an element of physical violence is often used
as a criterion for categorizing acts of sexual abuse against children as crimes
or not. Sexual harassment of children itself still tends to be narrowed down,
meaning that it is limited to forms of sexual contact by eliminating
non-contact sexual harassment forms such as pornography. Whether or not there
is an element of coercion is actually not significant in cases of sexual crimes
against children because of different understandings about sex between adults
and children.
Sexual violence is considered a crime with a
fairly high level of cruelty and is seen as very demeaning to human dignity.
Punishment of perpetrators of sexual violence does not eliminate the traumatic
feelings suffered by the child. Children are the pillar of the family and the
successors of the nation must be protected. But the fact is that the rise of
cases of sexual violence seems to make us all aware that children need to be
protected. So many children who experience this tragic thing are victims of
their families and in today's society.
The words "violence" and
"sexual" are two tribes that have different meanings. If traced, the
word violence is in harmony with the phrase "violence" in English.
The word is closely related to the Latin words visi and latus, the first
meaning is power or strength while the second is strength.
Child abuse is more of a form of physical abuse in
the presence of marks or wounds on the child's body. If violence against
children in the household is committed by parents, then it can be called
domestic violence. Acts of domestic violence that are included in acts of
domestic violence are giving suffering both physically and mentally beyond
certain limits to other people who are in the same house; such as spouses,
children or parents and the acts of violence are committed at home.
There is no single specific characteristic or personality
type that can be identified from a perpetrator of sexual violence against
children. In other words, anyone can become a perpetrator of sexual violence
against children or sexual violence. The ability of the perpetrator to control
the victim, either by deception or threats and violence, makes it difficult to
avoid this crime.
Data recorded at the Indonesian Child Protection
Commission (hereinafter abbreviated as KPAI) shows that cases of sexual
violence entering their institutions continue to increase. Various violations
of children's rights in 2021 still occur, both violations related to the fulfilment
of rights and related to special protection of children. Based on quite
fluctuating public complaint data, in 2019 there were 4,369 cases, in 2020 there
were 6,519 cases, and in 2021 there were 5,953 cases, with details of cases of
fulfilling the rights of the child 2971 cases, and special protection for
children 2982. 2,982 cases. The trend of cases in the special protection
cluster for children in 2021 is dominated by the 6 highest cases, namely first,
child victims of physical and/or psychological violence reaching 1,138 cases;
second, child victims of sexual crimes reached 859 cases; third, child victims
of pornography and cybercrime totaling 345 cases; fourth, child victims of
abuse and neglect reached 175 cases; fifth, 147 cases of children being
exploited economically and/or sexually; and sixth, children dealing with the
law as perpetrators in 126 cases(Reza, 2014).
Cases of physical and psychological violence,
child victims of abuse reached 574 cases, child victims of psychological
violence 515 cases, child victims of murder 35 cases, and child victims of
brawls there were 14 cases. Meanwhile, the highest complaints of cases of
sexual crimes against children came from 536 cases (62%) of children as victims
of sexual abuse, 285 cases (33%) of children as victims of rape/sexual
violence, 29 cases of same-sex abuse of children (3%) , and children as victims
of sexual violence, rape/sexual intercourse in 9 cases (1%)(Reza, 2014)
From the perspective of the perpetrators, the
perpetrators who committed physical and/or psychological violence against
victims were generally people who were known to the victims and to a lesser
extent unknown to the victims. The perpetrators were quite varied, namely
friends of the victims, neighbours, acquaintances of the victims, parents,
educators and education staff in the education unit and apparatus.
Based on the description of the data above, it
indicates that children are a group that is very vulnerable to crimes of sexual
violence because children are always positioned as weak or helpless and have a
high dependence on the adults around them. This is what makes children helpless
when threatened not to tell what happened. In almost every case that is
uncovered, the perpetrator is someone close to the victim.
Child protection provided by the state must be
able to guarantee the optimal fulfilment of children's rights for the
realization of justice and welfare for children. However, the protection
provided does not violate the rights of others and also does not violate
religious norms as norms that must be upheld for the purity of their teachings.
Child protection aims to guarantee the fulfilment of children's rights so that
they can live, grow and develop and participate optimally in accordance with
human dignity.
Based on the background that has been formulated
above, the writer is interested in raising this problem to become a research
entitled: "Legal Analysis of Offenders and Children as Victims of Sexual
Violence.
METHODS
This type of research falls into the category of normative
legal research, because in its analysis it uses library materials as a source
of research data. Normative research here is to analyze the factors that cause
children to become victims of sexual violence committed by those closest to
them and the obstacles in providing legal protection for children as victims of
sexual violence crimes. In legal research, this type is included in the
category of normative legal research or library legal research, therefore in
this study library materials constitute basic data which in research science is
classified as secondary data.
The data source is the object from which the data was
obtained because this research is classified as literature research, so all
data is secondary data consisting of legal materials. Therefore, this research
is a normative research in which library materials are the basis for
(knowledge) research classified as secondary data.
This research obtains from original
sources regarding the subject matter being discussed by this writer. Data
sources can be obtained through:
1)
The
Criminal Code (KUHP)
2)
Law
Number 11 of 2012 concerning the Juvenile Criminal Justice System.
3)
Law
Number 13 of 2006 Concerning the Protection of Witnesses and Victims.
4)
Law
No. 35 of 2014 concerning Amendments to Law no. 23 of 2002 concerning Child
Protection.
5)
Law
No. 39 of 1999 concerning Human Rights.
6)
Presidential
Regulation Number 75 of 2020 Concerning the Implementation of the Rights of
Child Victims and Children of Witnesses.
A. Factors Causing Children and Women to Become Victims of Sexual Violence
Perpetrated by Criminals
Crime against children is increasing day by day,
especially sexual violence against children which has recently become the most
common case in Indonesia, especially in the City of Ternate, North Maluku
Province, as shown by the number of cases of sexual intercourse with underage
children at the Ternate Resort Police, as follows:
Table 1
Number of Underage Sexual Affair Cases at the Ternate Resort Police
|
No |
Year |
Frequency |
Percentage% |
|
1 |
2019 |
2 |
8.33 |
|
2 |
2020 |
13 |
54.17 |
|
3 |
2021 |
5 |
20.83 |
|
4 |
2022 |
4 |
16.67 |
|
Total |
24 |
100 |
|
Source: Ternate Police PPA Unit
Based on the data table for the crime of
intercourse mentioned above during the last 4 (four) years from 2019 � 2022 in
Ternate City there were 24 (twenty four) cases of crime of intercourse against
minors, each totaling 2 cases (8.33 %) in 2019, whereas in 2020 there was an
increase in the number of reported cases to 13 cases (54.17%), in 2021 the
number of cases fell again to 5 cases (20.83%), and again decreased from 5
cases to 4 cases (16.67%) in August 2022.
This shows that cases of rape reported to the
Ternate Resort Police, from year to year cases of sexual intercourse with
minors fluctuate quite a bit, that is, they do not decrease but are not
permanent, that is, they can increase and vice versa, they can also decrease.
With this trend in cases, it is very worrying for law enforcement and the
people in Ternat City because children are vulnerable to becoming victims of
criminal acts of intercourse.
From the table above it can be seen that the
number of cases of sexual violence against children from 2019 to 2021 is 41
cases with various causative factors. There are several factors in the
occurrence of sexual violence against children, namely as follows:
1. Environmental factor
Sexual harassment and violence against children
has become a familiar phenomenon in society that makes people feel afraid and
worried about the child's growth and mentality. When parents feel that the
child is good, they have received good guidance, they understand what parents
are advising, but sometimes inversely proportional to what parents expect when
the child is outside the house. For this reason, when children are starting to
get to know the outside world, do socialization, and play together with their
friends, it is better to be accompanied, don't let children socialize too
widely, because the environment the child is in greatly influences his
behavior.
If there are many cases of sexual violence against
children that occur in the city of Ternate, and reports that are submitted to the
PPA unit of the Ternate Police, one of the factors that causes this is
environmental factors. The association of children who are too free to the
point where they are out of control by their parents, an environment where
children are too free to make friends with people they even just met, children
forget to go home. Even people who become friends with adults to children who
don't really understand the wider social world are very young to be influenced
by bad people.
One example of a case that occurred in 2021 is
that the child who became the victim was a child in grade 2 of junior high
school (junior high school), this child often went out at night hanging out
with friends who were not only friends from school but also many from outside.
By that time it was already late at night, when they dispersed from the hangout
place this child was offered by the perpetrator to be taken back to his house,
because this child felt confident in the perpetrator even though it was the
first time they met. So this child was taken home but in the middle of the
journey the perpetrator stopped and forced this child to go with the
perpetrator so that the perpetrator raped this child.
From the case above it can be seen that choosing
an environment to associate with is very important. The role of parents in
their supervision must pay more attention to who their children associate with,
children are still not able to think on a long scale about what children are
doing, so children really need guidance and direction from parents or those
closest to them.
The social environment is very important to pay
attention to, especially for children who often leave the house without their
parents knowing how their child gets along, children are very vulnerable to
invitations from outside with the lure of something. Children are not yet able
to think about what is good and what is bad, what is right and what is wrong.
Because the child he knows is only fun, he thinks it's all part of the game.
2. Law Enforcement Factors
The large number of cases of sexual violence
against children makes people afraid and feel uncomfortable in their household
and social life. This results in a safe and peaceful atmosphere that will not
be felt in the surrounding environment. Acts of sexual violence are acts that
harm other people because criminal acts of sexual violence are a form of
violation of social and legal norms. Thus those who commit crimes of sexual
violence are given criminal sanctions (penalties) in accordance with applicable
laws as a form of legal policy for the crimes he has committed.
Human behavior that is evil, immoral and
anti-social makes people angry and causes irritation among the people and is
very detrimental to the public. Therefore, these crimes should not be allowed
to continue to develop and grow in people's lives. The community as a whole,
together with the official institutions in charge of the police, prosecutors,
courts and even correctional institutions, and others are obliged to deal with
crime as far as possible. Thus, in order to be able to overcome sexual violence
crimes, it is necessary to enforce the law against perpetrators of sexual
violence by imposing punishments in accordance with the crimes that have been
committed to provide a deterrent effect on perpetrators.
In the case that law enforcement can run smoothly
and as well as possible so that crime prevention has a positive impact, then
there are factors that influence one of them is the statute factor in imposing
criminal sanctions (sentences) on perpetrators of crimes of sexual violence.
The law is a form of regulation in which it
regulates the imposition of criminal sanctions (punishments) for anyone who
commits a crime, in this case the law in question relates to sexual violence
against children. The function of the law itself is that every existing rule
can be a means used to become an alternative in overcoming the level of sexual
violence against children.
In order for law enforcement to run as stipulated
in the law, law enforcement officials are needed who are both the parties that
make up and apply the law. Therefore, in addition to law enforcement laws, they
should do their job properly in terms of upholding the law in an effort to
tackle sexual violence.
Each of these law enforcers has a position and
role in society, so that this position and role greatly influences their
respective work in terms of law enforcement. Law enforcers are a group of role
models in society who should have certain abilities in accordance with the
aspirations of the community. As role models, they should be able to choose the
right time and environment in introducing new legal norms or rules, as well as
setting a good example.
One factor that becomes important in law
enforcement is the availability of facilities or facilities. Means or
facilities are one of the factors that also affect law enforcement. With
adequate facilities, law enforcement can run properly because in the case of
law enforcers carrying out their duties, they must be accompanied by supporting
facilities. Without the means or facilities, it is impossible for law
enforcement to take place quickly. The meaning of these facilities or
facilities includes, among other things, educated and skilled human resources,
good organization, adequate equipment, adequate finances.
3. Technology Factor
In every culture there is always knowledge or
science and technology, which is used as a reference for interpreting and
understanding the environment and its contents, as well as being used as a tool
for exploiting, processing and utilizing it to fulfill human needs. Science and
technology can develop through various forms of innovation and engineering. The
usefulness of science and technology for humans is highly dependent on the
underlying values, morals, norms and laws. It must be admitted that in this day
and age, humans inevitably have to keep up with the developments of the
existing era. If not, they will also be left out of information and may also be
ostracized or alienated by circumstances. However, the use of technology does
not maximize functionality and does not use it according to needs, so the
performance will not be effective. With the increasing sophistication of
technology, almost all human roles are replaced by "robots".
Technological advances such as cell phones, television, radio, and the internet
cannot be avoided in this life, because technological advances go hand in hand
with advances in science.
Advances in communication technology on the one
hand have positive impacts such as making it easier for humans to interact with
one another, making it easier for humans to obtain the information they need.
Easily the information obtained by this community can influence the
perspective, lifestyle and culture in a particular society. On the other hand,
technology also has a negative impact. For example, existing technology and
communications are widely used to carry out deviant behavior such as fraud,
cheating on national exams, downloading pornographic sites or uploading
pornographic images or videos that can lead to the decline of the nation. This
negative impact greatly affects life in society.
From the explanation above, the authors conclude
that indeed one of the factors that causes sexual violence is the technological
factor, the use of technology in a negative direction. The use of social media
that is too free, accesses and searches for things that are inappropriate for
consumption. Moreover, to be motivated to commit crimes. This has a huge impact
on victims of crime, for example children who become victims, children who
should go to school to study so they can become the nation's successors, but
because of the bad behavior of people, children become victims and also have an
impact on the future of children. Therefore, childhood is a time when children
are in the process of growing up. Children must be protected from all possible
violence against children, especially sexual violence.
According to the author, efforts to protect
children must be provided in a complete, comprehensive and comprehensive
manner, impartially to a group or group of children. The efforts given are
carried out by considering the best interests of the child by remembering their
right to live and develop, and respecting their opinion. Efforts to protect
children mean the realization of justice in a society.
This assumption is reinforced by the opinion that
has been stated correctly that "protecting children is essentially
protecting the family, society, nation and state in the future".
4. Monitoring Factor
Supervision is a systematic effort to set
performance standards in planning to design information feedback systems, to
compare actual performance with predetermined standards, to determine whether a
deviation has occurred, and to take corrective action. This expression shows
how important child protection efforts are for the future continuity of a
community, both the smallest community, namely the family, and the largest
community, namely the state. This means that by seeking protection for children
in these communities not only upholding children's rights, but also at the same
time investing in their lives in the future.
Here, it can be said that there has been a
symbiotic mutualism between the two. The function of supervision is to be able
to keep abreast of developments. Thus, in handling sexual violence against
children, there needs to be synergy between the family, society and the state.
In addition, the handling of cases of sexual violence against children should
be holistic and integrated. All sides need improvement and treatment, both from
the medical side, the individual side, the legal aspect (in this case there are
still many weaknesses), as well as social support. If sexual violence against
children is not taken seriously, it can have broad social impacts on society.
The healing of psychological trauma due to sexual violence must receive great
attention from all parties involved.
Various factors cause cases of sexual violence
against children and the impact felt by children as victims both physically,
psychologically and socially. Trauma to children who experience sexual violence
they will experience for the rest of their lives. Physical wounds may be able
to heal, but wounds that are stored in the mind don't necessarily disappear
easily. It should be a concern because of the children. Apart from having to be
protected, it is also because it is in the hands of children that the future of
a region or nation will develop.
Sexual violence against children can occur
anywhere and anytime and can be committed by anyone, be it family members,
school authorities, or other people. Therefore, children need to be equipped
with the right knowledge of sexuality so that children can avoid sexual
violence. Seeing the impact caused by sexual violence experienced by children
who are victims, in handling sexual violence against children, the active role
of society, individuals, is very important. , and government.
There needs to be a system-based approach in
handling child sexual violence. An effective child protection system requires
interrelated components. These components include social welfare systems for
children and families, a justice system that complies with international
standards, and mechanisms to encourage appropriate behavior in society. In
addition, a supporting legal and policy framework is also needed as well as a
data and information system for child protection.
B. Efforts to Provide Legal Protection for Victims of Sexual Intercourse and
Rape in the Criminal Justice System.
1. Legal Protection for Children as Victims of Underage Sexual Intercourse
The presence of a child as a creature of God
Almighty has basic rights like other human beings, so that no human or other
party can take away these rights. In the life of the nation and state, children
are the future of the nation and the next generation of the nation's ideals so
that every child has the right to survival, growth and development,
participation and is entitled to protection from acts of violence and
discrimination as well as civil rights and freedoms.(Tjahjanto, 2008). The position of children in society is very vulnerable, considering
their physical and mental conditions that are not yet strong and mature. The
recent phenomenon of decency crimes places children most often involved in
these crimes, as perpetrators or victims.
A proper understanding of children's rights is
clearly very important and the main thing to do considering that children have
all the hopes of the Indonesian people. Thus, it can be understood that
children are a form of investment which is an indicator of the success of a
nation in carrying out development. The success of child development will
determine the quality of human resources in the future(Widodo, 2016). Article 28 B paragraph (2) of the 1945
Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia (hereinafter abbreviated as the 1945
Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia) reads that:(Sugiyantica, 2014).
"Every child has the right to survive, grow
and develop and is entitled to protection from violence and
discrimination".
Law Number 17 of 2016 concerning Stipulation of
Government Regulation in Lieu of Law Number 1 of 2016 regarding the second
amendment to Law Number 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection to Become Law
(hereinafter referred to as the Child Protection Law) in the provisions of
Article 1 point (1) qualify that said child is someone who is not yet 18
(eighteen) years old, including children who are still in the womb(RAHMAN, 2017). The Child Protection Law has provided the widest
possible opportunity for a child to grow and develop optimally both physically
and mentally so that an ideal generation will be created. Therefore, if there
is sexual violence against children, of course this action is a form of child
abuse.
If a child becomes a victim of crime, then for
legal protection, of course, more attention must be paid because children are
the next generation of the nation. Rape experienced by child victims certainly
has a traumatic effect or a deep bad memory on the child, this affects the
behavior, lifestyle and behavior of the child in the future. Thus, the
increasing number of cases of rape against children proves that this problem is
not just an ordinary problem. However, it is a serious problem that must be
addressed by the government.
Sexual violence in the context of rape is often
confused. Whether there is an element of physical violence is often used as a
criterion to categorize acts of sexual abuse against children as crimes or not.
Sexual harassment against children themselves still tends to be narrowed down,
meaning limited to forms of sexual contact by ignoring non-contact sexual
harassment forms such as pornography. Whether or not there was an element of
coercion is actually not significant in cases of sexual crimes against children
because of different understandings about sex between adults and children.
child.
Sexual intercourse with minors is considered a
crime with a fairly high level of cruelty and is seen as very demeaning to
human dignity. Punishment of perpetrators of sexual violence does not eliminate
the traumatic feelings suffered by the child. Children are the pillar of the
family and the successors of the nation must be protected. However, the fact
that cases of sexual violence are rampant makes us all aware that children need
to be protected. So many children who experience this tragic thing are victims
of their families and in today's society.
The child's condition is more of a form of
physical abuse with marks or wounds on the child's body. If violence against
children in the household is committed by parents, then it can be called
domestic violence. Acts of domestic violence that are included in acts of
domestic violence are giving suffering both physically and mentally beyond
certain limits to other people who are in the same house; such as spouses,
children or parents and the acts of violence are committed at home.
There is no single specific characteristic or
personality type that can be identified from a perpetrator of sexual violence
against children. In other words, anyone can become a perpetrator of sexual
violence against children or sexual violence. The ability of the perpetrator to
control the victim, either by deception or threats and violence, makes it
difficult to avoid this crime.
Data recorded at the Indonesian Child Protection
Commission (hereinafter abbreviated as KPAI) shows that cases of sexual
violence entering their institutions continue to increase. Various violations
of children's rights in 2021 still occur, both violations related to the fulfilment
of rights and related to special protection of children. Based on quite
fluctuating public complaint data, in 2019 there were 4,369 cases, in 2020
there were 4,116 cases, and in 2021 there were 5,953 cases, with details of
2971 cases of Fulfilment of Children's Rights, and 2982 Special Protection of
Children Number of public complaints related to special child protection cases
in 2021 as many as 2,982 cases. The trend of cases in the special protection
cluster for children in 2021 is dominated by the 6 highest cases, namely first,
child victims of physical and/or psychological violence reaching 1,138 cases;
second, child victims of sexual crimes reached 859 cases; third, child victims
of pornography and cybercrime totaling 345 cases; fourth, child victims of
abuse and neglect reached 175 cases; fifth, 147 cases of children being
exploited economically and/or sexually; and sixth, children dealing with the
law as perpetrators in 126 cases(Indonesian Child Protection Commission,
2022).
Cases of physical and psychological violence,
child victims of abuse reached 574 cases, child victims of psychological violence
515 cases, child victims of murder 35 cases, and child victims of brawls there
were 14 cases. Meanwhile, the highest complaints of cases of sexual crimes
against children came from the type of child as a victim of sexual abuse in 536
cases (62%), child as a victim of sexual intercourse in 285 cases (33%), child
as a victim of same-sex abuse in 29 cases (3%)(Indonesian
Child Protection Commission, 2022). From the perspective of the perpetrators, the
perpetrators who committed physical and/or psychological violence against
victims were generally people who were known to the victims and to a lesser
extent unknown to the victims. The perpetrators were quite varied, namely
friends of the victims, neighbors, acquaintances of the victims, parents,
educators and education staff in the education unit and apparatus.
Based on the description of the data above, it
indicates that children are a group that is very vulnerable to crimes of sexual
violence because children are always positioned as weak or helpless and have a
high dependence on the adults around them. This is what makes children helpless
when threatened not to tell what happened. In almost every case that is
uncovered, the perpetrator is someone close to the victim.
Child protection provided by the state must be
able to guarantee the optimal fulfilment of children's rights for the
realization of justice and welfare for children. However, the protection
provided does not violate the rights of others and also does not violate
religious norms as norms that must be upheld for the purity of their teachings.
Child protection aims to guarantee the fulfilment of children's rights so that
they can live, grow and develop and participate optimally in accordance with
human dignity.
Children who are victims of criminal acts,
hereinafter referred to as child victims in Article 1 paragraph (4) of Law
Number 11 of 2012 concerning the Juvenile Criminal Justice System, are children
who are not yet 18 (eighteen) years old who experience physical, mental and/or
suffering. or economic loss caused by a crime(Ariani, 2014). Child victims and child witnesses in article
89 of Law Number 11 of 2012 concerning the Juvenile Justice System are entitled
to all the protections and rights regulated in the provisions of laws and
regulations. Article 90 states that in addition to the rights that have been
regulated in the provisions of laws and regulations, child victims are entitled
to:
a.
Medical rehabilitation and social rehabilitation efforts, both within and
outside the institution;
b.
Guarantee of safety, both physical, mental and social; And
c.
Ease of obtaining information about the progress of the case(Ariani, 2014).
2. Children's Rights as Victims
A child who becomes a victim of a crime,
especially rape, has various rights and obligations that must be carried out
according to the abilities related to his age. These rights and obligations
include the following:
a. Rights of Children as Victims
The rights of children who are victims of criminal
acts are:
1) Receive physical assistance (medical first aid,
clothing, shelter, etc.).
2) Get help solving problems (reporting, legal
advice, and defense).
3) Get back his rights.
4) Get coaching and rehabilitation.
5) Refuse to be a witness, if this will endanger
himself.
6) Obtain protection from threats by the victim-maker
when reporting or becoming a witness.
7) Obtain compensation (restitution, compensation)
from the perpetrator (according to ability) or other parties concerned for the
sake of justice and welfare in question.
8) Refuse compensation for the common good.
9) Using legal remedies (rechtsmiddelen).
b. Obligations of Children as Victims
The obligations of children as victims are:
1) Do not make victims by taking revenge (vigilante).
2) Participating with society prevents further
victimization.
3) Prevent the destruction of the victim maker either
by oneself or others.
4) Willing to be fostered or self-development not to
become a victim again.
5) Do not demand compensation that is not in
accordance with the ability of the victim.
6) Provide opportunities for victims to provide
compensation to victims according to their abilities (in
installments/remuneration).
7) Be a witness if you don't endanger yourself and
there is a guarantee of safety for yourself(Arsad & Faisal, 2022).
The rights of the child in Article 1 paragraph
(12) are part of Human Rights which must be guaranteed, protected and fulfilled
by parents, family, community, State, government and local government.(RAHMAN, 2017). Child protection in Article 1 paragraph (2) of
Law Number 35 of 2014 concerning amendments to Law Number 23 of 2002 concerning
Child Protection is all activities to guarantee and protect children and their
rights so that they can live, grow, develop and participate optimally in
accordance with human dignity, and receive protection from violence and
discrimination. Article 20 states that the State, government, local government,
community, family, and parents or guardians are obliged and responsible for the
implementation of child protection.(Republic of Indonesia, 2014). Meanwhile, protection in Article 1 paragraph (6)
of Presidential Regulation Number 75 of 2020 concerning the Implementation of
the Rights of Child Victims and Children of Witnesses is all efforts to fulfill
rights and provide assistance to provide a sense of security for child
witnesses and child victims carried out by witness and victim protection
agencies. or other institutions in accordance with the provisions of the
legislation(Ritonga, Din, & Sulaiman, 2021).
Judging from the nature of child protection, it
can also be divided into juridical protection, including protection in the
field of civil law and in criminal law, which in turn is non-juridical
protection, covering protection in the social, health, and education fields (Maulana, 2000). Article 15 of Law Number 35 of 2014 states that
every child has the right to receive protection from:
1) Abuse in political activities;
2) Involvement in armed conflict;
3) Involvement in social unrest;
4) Involvement in events that contain elements of
violence;
5) Involvement in war;
6) Sexual crimes(Republic of Indonesia, 2014).
Article 1 paragraph (15) special protection is a
form of protection that is received by children in certain situations and
conditions to get a guarantee of a sense of security against threats that
endanger themselves and their lives in their development. Article 59 the
government, local government and other state institutions have the obligation
and responsibility to provide special protection to children. This special
protection is given to children:
1) Child in an emergency situation.
2) Children in conflict with the law.
3) Children from minority and isolated groups.
4) Children who are economically and/or sexually
exploited.
5) Children who are victims of abuse of narcotics,
alcohol, psychotropics and other addictive substances.
6) Children who are victims of pornography.
7) Children with HIV/AIDS.
8) Child victims of abduction, sale and/or
trafficking.
9) Child victims of physical and/or psychological
violence.
10)Child victims of sexual crimes.
11)Children of victims of terrorist networks.
12)Children with disabilities.
13)Child victims of abuse and neglect.
14)Children with deviant social behavior. And
15) Children who are victims of stigmatization from
labeling are related to the condition of their parents.
Article 69 A of the Child Protection Law states
that special protection for child victims of sexual crimes is carried out
through:(Prajnaparamita, 2018)
1) Education about reproductive health, religious
values, and moral values.
2) Social rehabilitation.
3) Psychosocial assistance from treatment to
recovery. And
4) Provision of protection and assistance at every
level of examination starting from investigation, prosecution, up to
examination in court.
According to the researcher's opinion, all the
ideals and hopes set out above, as an effort to protect children who are
victims of sexual crimes will only be empty dreams if there are no applicable
efforts to make them happen. The efforts that need to be made to achieve this
progress must improve education because through strong and well-established
education the next generation will be able to compete in the increasingly
sophisticated era of globalization and always experience changes at any time.(Hasanah, 2022).
If you pay attention to the rights and obligations
of the child mentioned above, it is an effort where a person's human rights
must still be considered in efforts to protect children, because children, at
their age, are very vulnerable to being victims of abuse from adults, they do
not understand and understand that their rights have been taken away by people
who make children as victims in a crime.
The fulfilment of children's rights can be applied
to legal rules that protect children's rights based on Article 18 of Law Number
17 of 2016 concerning Child Protection in conjunction with Law Number 35 of
2014 concerning Amendments to Law Number 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection
states that(Yustisia & Pustaka, 2016)v: �every child who is a victim or perpetrator of a crime has the right�������� obtain
legal assistance and other assistance.
Furthermore, legal protection for children as
victims of criminal acts of intercourse and subsequent obscenity has been
specifically regulated in Law Number 35 of 2014 concerning amendments to Law
Number 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection, namely Article 81. In addition
to Article 81 also regulated in the provisions of Article 82 of Law Number 35
of 2014 concerning Amendment to Law Number 23 of 2002 concerning Child
Protection which specifically regulates the fulfilment of Child Protection.
This is where the philosophical basis behind
the importance of crime victims (their families) gets protection. The
importance of victims obtaining recovery as an effort to balance the conditions
of victims who experience disturbances, was correctly stated by Muladi when he
stated: victims of crime need to be protected because:
First, society is considered as a form of an
institutionalized belief system (system of institutionalized trust). This
belief is integrated through the norms expressed in the institutional
structure. The occurrence of a crime against the victim will mean the destruction
of the belief system so that the regulation of criminal law and other laws
relating to the victim will function as a means of restoring this belief
system. Second, there are social contract and social solidarity arguments
because it can be said to monopolize all social reactions to crime and
prohibits private actions. Therefore, if there are victims of crime, the state
pays attention to the needs of victims by improving services and regulating
rights. Third, victim protection which is usually associated with one of the
goals of punishment, namely conflict resolution. With the resolution of
conflicts caused by criminal acts, it will restore balance and bring a sense of
peace in society.
The importance of protecting victims of crime
cannot be separated from the consequences experienced by victims after being
raped. Victims not only experience physical suffering but also psychological
suffering. The issue of protection for victims of rape has always been an
interesting issue to scrutinize, because the problem of protecting victims of
rape is not only related to providing protection, but also related to the
obstacles they face. It is not easy to provide protection to rape victims
because there are several factors that become obstacles.
The victim factor plays an important role in
overcoming or resolving this rape case, this requires the courage of the victim
to report what happened to her to the police, because in general the victim
gets physical violence and psychological pressure from the perpetrator of the
rape and this makes the victim feel scared and traumatized . The forms of
sexual violence due to rape can be categorized into two, namely:
1) Verbal Sexual Violence
Forms of verbal sexual violence are more carried
out in the form of invitations or words that are submitted to other people but
lead to something related to sexuality, for example:
a) Joke, tease the opposite sex, or ask questions
about sexuality in discussions or chats that are not specifically discussing
sexual matters.
b) Convey or ask other people about sexual desires or
sexual desires that have been made by that person, which makes that person
uncomfortable.
c) Forced to have intimate relations as practiced by
a husband and wife but outside of a legal or unwanted marriage, without consent
and the action is followed by coercion both physically and mentally.
2) Non Verbal Sexual Violence
Forms of non-verbal sexual violence are acts in
the form of invitations to use writing or actions that do not directly come
into contact between the perpetrator and the victim. Subjects of verbal sexual
violence and non-verbal sexual violence can be committed by men and women as
well as the objects or victims can be men and women(Hidayati, 2018).
Women experience multiple suffering from rape
committed by men. This suffering is not only in the form of coercion during
sexual intercourse, but the risk of getting pregnant outside, bearing a fairly
heavy mental burden after the rape incident and during her pregnancy, the heavy
social pressure she gets from the surrounding environment, and not to mention
when the child she is born does not have a father who legal, even though the
convicted person of rape can be determined as the father of the baby by the
court, but often the perpetrators of rape deny their responsibility(Nyoman United, 2017)
What's more, the most difficult thing is if there
is more than one rapist, this makes it more difficult to find the biological
father of the baby conceived by the woman who was the victim of the rape.
Evidence of the fact that sexual violence can be proven, based on data from the
National Commission on Violence Against Women (CATAHU) on March 5, 2022,
reports that complaints to Komnas Perempuan have also increased drastically,
namely 60% from 1,413 cases in 2019 to 2,389 cases in 2020 until the January-
In July 2021, there were 2,500 escalations of violence against women. Where
there were 229 cases of rape (Catahu, 5/3/2021).
For perpetrators of rape crimes, they must receive
very severe laws so that the perpetrators feel the deterrent effect of what
they have done. We can see the criminal sanctions that can be applied to the
perpetrator in accordance with his actions, namely, in Article 285 of the
Criminal Code which has the following elements:
a) Whoever, the term element of whoever refers to
anyone who can be subject to this element, what is meant by whoever is a man or
a man who has intercourse with him.
b) By violence or threats of violence, what is meant
by someone committing violence is that it can make a person powerless or
unconscious, so a woman can only be said to be raped when there are scars on
the woman's body or the clothes worn by the woman are torn.
c) Forcing, coercive actions can be done with deeds
and can also be done with words or speech.
d) A woman who is not his wife, in the fourth element
of the crime of rape is a woman who is not his wife, so if it is against his
own wife then this article will not apply.
e) Having intercourse, what is meant by this element
is that the male genitalia must have entered the woman's vagina in such a way
that in the end the sperm has ejected.
f) By him, what is meant by him is the word by
himself the person who commits violence or threats of violence that has forced
a woman who is not his wife to have intercourse with him(Sugandhi, 1980).
From the elements of the article, it can be proven
in court proceedings. The protection for victims of rape is carried out during
the judicial process, as follows:(Wedani & Dananjaya, 2015)
a) Before the court hearing
The legal protection given to victims of rape was
first given by the police when the victim made a report. Victims are placed in
the Special Service Room (RPK) where victims of violence or sexual abuse for
children and women can report their cases.
b) During a court hearing
During the trial process, the victim gave
testimony accompanied by members of LBH/NGO so that the victim could be more
calm and not feel afraid during the trial. Considering that the victim is still
psychologically unstable and feels depressed after undergoing examination
during the judicial process, assistance is needed by the victim.
c) After court
After the perpetrator has been sentenced by a
judge, then in accordance with Article 5 paragraph (1) letter hs/dm of Law
Number 13 of 2006, the victim has the right to receive protection, which
includes the following: Knowing that the convict is released; Get a new
identity; Get a new residence; Obtain reimbursement of transportation costs as
needed; Get legal advice; and/or Obtain temporary living expenses assistance
until the final protection deadline.
CONCLUSION
Efforts
to provide legal protection for victims of underage sexual intercourse and rape
in the criminal justice system are carried out through preventive and
repressive approaches, both by the community and the government (through law
enforcement officials), such as providing protection/supervision from various
threats that could endanger the life of the victim, provision of adequate
medical or legal assistance, examination and judicial processes. The background
to the need for legal protection for victims of criminal acts is because
victims experience physical and psychological suffering whose recovery requires
quite a long time to recover so that when facing the examination and trial
process they need to get legal protection.
The
accommodation of children's rights as victims of underage sexual intercourse
and women as victims of rape during the investigation process at the Ternate
Police is in accordance with the positive law that applies in the criminal
justice system. As for legal protection for children as victims of criminal
acts of intercourse and subsequent obscenity, it has been specifically
regulated in Law Number 35 of 2014 concerning amendments to Law Number 23 of
2002 concerning Child Protection, namely Article 81. Apart from Article 81 it
is also regulated in in the provisions of Article 82 of Law Number 35 of 2014
concerning Amendment to Law Number 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection which
specifically regulates the fulfilment of Child Protection.
REFERENCES
Ariani, Nevey Varida. (2014). Implementation of Law Number 11
of 2012 concerning the juvenile criminal justice system in an effort to protect
the interests of children. Journal of Legal Media, 21(1), 16.
Arsad,
Jamal Hi, & Faisal, Faisal. (2022). The Rights of Women and Children
Victims of Rapes: Study at Ternate Resort Police. International Journal of
Social Science Research and Review, 5(10), 359�371.
Hasanah,
Titin Uswatun Nur. (2022). Spiritual Mental Therapy Techniques in Growing
Religiosity in Ex-Psychotics at BRSPDM "Margo Laras" Pati. IAIN HOLY.
Hidayati,
Holy. (2018). ii LEGAL PROTECTION OF CHILD VICTIMS OF SEXUAL VIOLENCE IN THE
PERSPECTIVE OF ISLAMIC LAW (Case Study: at the Social Service for Women's
Empowerment and Child Protection, Kulon Progo Regency, Yogyakarta).
Indonesia,
Child Protection Commission. (2022). Records of Violations of Children's Rights
in 2021 and Projection of Oversight of the Implementation of Child Protection
in 2022. Press Release.
Indonesia,
Republic. (2014). Law Number 35 of 2014 concerning Amendments to Law Number 23
of 2002 concerning Child Protection. Jakarta: Ministry of Women's Empowerment
and Child Protection.
Maulana,
Hasan Wadong. (2000). Introduction to Advocacy and Child Protection Law. PT
Gramedia Widiasrana Indonesia, Jakarta.
Nyoman
United, P. (2017). Legal Protection for Women Victims of Sexual Violence as
Perpetrators of Abortus Provocatus Indications of Rape. Diponegoro Law Review,
6(1), 1�17.
Prajnaparamita,
Kanyaka. (2018). Child Labor Protection. Administrative Law and Governance
Journal, 1(2), 215�230.
RAHMAN,
RAHMAN. (2017). Implementation of Law No. 35 of 2014 concerning Amendments to
Law N0. 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection Against Child Trafficking Crime
Cases. Tadulako University.
Reza,
Hillman. (2014). The Role of the Indonesian Child Protection Commission (Kpai)
in Addressing Sexual Violence Against Children.
Ritonga,
Erlin, Din, Mohd, & Sulaiman, Sulaiman. (2021). Legal Protection Through
Restitution for Child Victims of Sexual Crimes (Research in Aceh Jaya
District). Law Enforcement Scientific Journal, 8(2), 121�129.
Sugandhi,
R. (1980). The Criminal Code of the Indonesian Criminal Code follows the
explanation. Surabaya National Business, Surabaya.
Sugiyantica,
Rizca. (2014). Implementation of Article 28b Paragraph (2) of the 1945
Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia Regarding the Protection of Children
from Violence in the City of Surakarta.
Tjahjanto,
Eka. (2008). Implementation of Labor Laws and Regulations as Legal Protection
Against the Exploitation of Child Labor. Diponegoro University, Semarang.
Wedani,
Ni Putu Ari Manik, & Dananjaya, Nyoman S. (2015). Protection for victims of
rape during the criminal justice process. Udayana Law Masters Journal Vol,
3(3).
Widodo,
Guntarto. (2016). The Juvenile Criminal System as Perpetrators of Criminal Acts
Perspective of Law Number 11 of 2012 concerning the Juvenile Criminal Justice
System. Surya Kencana Dua Journal: Dynamics of Law and Justice Issues, 6(1),
65�67.
Yustisia,
Vision Team, & Readers, Visimedia. (2016). Consolidation of the Child
Protection Act: RI Law No. 23/2002 & RI Law No. 35/2014. VisiMedia.
|
Copyright holders: Rini Angriani, Syawal
Abdulajid, Suwarti (2023) |
|
First publication right: |
|
This article is licensed under: |