Journal of Social Science

 

 

 

 

 
Analysis Conextivity Sidewalk Design In Tasikmalaya School Area

 

 

Yogi Arisandi1 Khusnul Khotimah2

1Politeknik Transportasi Darat Indonesia-STTD, Cibitung No.9 Bekasi and Postcode, Indonesia

2Balitbanghub, Merdeka Timur, Jakarta and Postcode, Indonesia

 

 

A R T I C L E   I N F O                         a B S T R A C T

 

 

AIJ use only:

Received  date : 30 May 2020

Revised date : 15 June 2020

Accepted date : 20 July 2020

 

Keywords:

Sidewalk

School Area

Pedestrian Conextivity

Design Conextivity

 

 

 

 

In some areas of Tasikmalaya, there is an education zone. Conditions in the zone, some students are forced to walk on the road because of the unavailability of sidewalks or dealing with the traffic vehicles passing by and very unfriendly to school children. To improve the safety, comfort and safety of pedestrian users, it is necessary to plan the needs of integrated pedestrian facilities in Tasikmalaya Regency. This study using pedestrian analysis method that is done on sidewalk and pedestrian way and method of alignment analysis. It was found that the volume of vehicles> 1000 vehicles / 12 hours and pedestrian volume> 300orang / 12 hours. Pedestrian facilities such as sidewalks are indispensable in the education zone of Tasikmalaya Regency to minimize conflicts (vehicles and pedestrians). In one of the research sites, namely on Jl. K. H. Zaenal Musthafa requires pelican crossing because of the huge volume of vehicles and the very high volume of pedestrians. Integrated pedestrian concept is done by connecting Jl. Paledang with Jl. Garut-Tasikmalaya, Jl. Bantar Payung- Jl.Garut-Tasikmalaya.

     

 

 


 


Introduction*

 

Currently in Tasikmalaya Regency as mandated by Law no. 22 of 2009 on Road Traffic and Transportation and Presidential Instruction No. 4 of 2013 on the Road Safety Action Decade Program, requires the government to provide policies for the safety of its citizens.

The purpose of this research is to know the requirement of pedestrian facility at research location in Tasikmalaya Regency which is safe, comfortable, and humane so as to fulfill the needs of pedestrian users both in terms of number and standard of its provider.

                                                                                                                                           

*  Corresponding author.

E-mail address: [email protected]

      Article with open access under license

         

 

Besides, in this research, the planning of integration between the pedestrian paths so that the linkage of pedestrian paths to the building structure, the accessibility of the environment, and the transportation system

 

Method

 

Location and Time of Study

The research location in this study is Tasikmalaya Regency, West Java. This research was conducted in 2019 for 3 months.

 

 

Method of Collecting Data

 

1.   Primary Data

Journal of Social Science | Jsss.co.id 100

 
The primary data collection method in this study was observing and surveying the field. Primary data in this research are as follows.

Survey of school location inventory;

Car traffic enumeration survey; and

Pedestrian traffic surveys survey.

 

2.   Secondary Data

Secondary data collection method in this research is to take the required data in relevant agencies and search for various sources relevant to the research topic.

 

Survey Method

 

1.   Survey of school location inventory

The school site inventory survey was conducted by walking along the road segments in Tasikmalaya District and determining the location of schools that have direct access to roads.

 

2.   Survey of traffic enumeration

The vehicle traffic enumeration survey was conducted on road segments that were direct access from school locations. Survey conducted at 06.00-07.00 where in that time period is the peak time of school children to go to school location.

 

3.   Pedestrian traffic surveys survey

Pedestrian traffic surveys are conducted at school location points. The survey was conducted to obtain pedestrian data that travels across and across the street. Survey conducted at 06.00-07.00 where in that time period is the peak time of school children to go to school location.

 

Analysis Method

 

1.   Pedestrian Analysis Method

 

a.     Sidewalk

* PV2

   Formulation of crossing facilities based on volume of pedestrian (P) and volume of vehicle (V)

 
Sidewalks can be directed to roads with a pedestrian volume of more than 300 people per 12 hours (06.00-18.00) and more than 1,000 kendraan vehicles per 12 hours (06.00-18.00). The pavement free space is not less than 2.5 meters and the free depth is not less than 1 meter. Side freedom is not less than 0.3 meters. Planning of the installation of utilities other than having to meet the pavement free space must also comply with the provisions in the user manual for the installation of the utility.

 

The width of the sidewalk should be able to serve the volume of existing pedestrians. The minimum width of the sidewalk can be seen in the table below.

 

Table 1.  The minimum width of the sidewalk

Classification of Road Plans

Min Standard. (m)

Min.Width (Exception)

Type

Class I

3,0

1,5

 

Class II

3,0

1,5

 

Class III

1,5

1,0

Source : Tata Cara Perencanaan Fasilitas Pejalan Kaki di Kawasan Perkotaan, 1995

Information :
Minimum width is used on bridges of 50 meters or more in tunnels where the volume of pedestrian traffic is 300-500 persons per 12 hours.

 

b.     Crossing Facility

 

Pedestrian crosswalk facilities are closely related to the sidewalk, then pedestrian crossing facilities can be a sidewalk extension. For crossings with zebra cross and pelican crossing should be placed as close as possible to the intersection. The location of the crossing must be clearly visible to the rider and placed perpendicular to the axis of the road.

The basis for determining the type of ferry facilities is as follows:

 

Table 2.  Crossing Facilities Based on PV2*

No.

PV2

P

V

Rekomendation

1

> 108

50 - 1100

300 – 500

Zebra Cross

2

> 2 x 108

50 - 1100

400 – 750

Zebra Cross wit a waiting rack

3

> 108

50 - 1100

> 500

Pelican

4

> 108

> 1100

> 300

Pelican

5

> 2 x 108

50 - 1100

> 750

Pelican with a waiting rack

6

> 2 x 108

> 1100

> 400

Pelican with a waiting rack

Source : Tata Cara Perencanaan Fasilitas Pejalan Kaki di Kawasan Perkotaan, 1995

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Source : Tata Cara Perencanaan Fasilitas Pejalan Kaki di Kawasan Perkotaan, 1995

 

Picture 1.      Dasar penentuan fasilitas penyeberangan berdasarkan PV2

 

2.   Conextivity Analysis Method

The integrity analysis is used to obtain optimal results in the planning of pedestrian facilities that are connected between the pedestrian path to the structure of the building, the accessibility between environments, and the transportation system. The concept of integration is assessed through its connectivity index. The area of pedestrian ups and downs connected by a complex network of pedestrian facilities means having a high spatial interaction pattern. To know the strength of interaction of a region is used index of connectivity which is formulated as follows:

             e

α  = ----------

             v

Description:

α = connectivity index

e = number of pedestrian networks

v = number of pedestrians / pull of a pedestrian

 

results and discussion

 

Research sites

The location of the research based on the survey of school location inventory that has been done is as follows:

1.   SD Negeri 3 Mangunreja on Jl. Paledang;

2.   SD Negeri Cintawana on Jl. Peledang;

3.   SD Negeri 1 dan 2 Cipakat on Jl. K. H. Zaenal Musthafa;

4.   SMA Negeri 1 Singaparna on Jl. K. H. Zaenal Musthafa;

5.   SMP Negeri Padakembang and SD Negeri 3 Cisaruni on Jl. Bantarpayung;

6.   SD Negeri 2 Cintaraja on Jl. Raya Cintaraja;

7.   SD Negeri 1 Cintaraja and SD Negeri 1 Cikunir on Jl. Raya Singaparna;

 

Vehicle Volume

Vehicle traffic enumeration surveys are divided into 3 types of vehicles, namely light vehicles (LV), heavy vehicles (HV), and motorcycles (MC). Based on the traffic survey results that have been done, it can be seen that the volume of vehicles on each road segment is relatively large. Motorcycles are the most vehicles (dominating) the volume of vehicles on each road segment at the study site. In addition, it can be seen that the volume of heavy vehicles (buses and trucks) has considerable volumes on several streets at the survey sites. Vehicle volume based on vehicle traffic survey can be seen in the table below.

 

Table 3.  Vehicle volume

No.

Street Name

Arus Total

Veh./12Hours

smp/12Hours

1

Jl. Paledang

West

2856

1909.95

East

2627

1751

2

Jl. K.H. Zaenal Musthafa

North

3613

2368.1

 

South

9911

6233.9

3

Jl. Bantarpayung

North

4310

2429.3

South

4565

2528.75

4

Jl. Raya Cintaraja

West

9512

6960.65

 

East

2151

1615

5

Jl. Raya Singaparna

North

11883

6417.5

 

South

10778

5809.75

Source : Survey results and data processing, 2019

 

Walking Volume

Based on the results of the survey that has been done, it can be seen that the number of pedestrians is relatively large on some roads in the study sites. However, there is an enormous volume of pedestrians on K. H. Zaenal Musthafa road. This is because the segment Jl. K. H. Zaenal Musthafa is not only a school location, but there are residential areas that have direct access to highways and office locations.

Table 4. 

Journal of Social Science | Jsss.co.id 102

 
Pedestrian volume

No

Street Name

Pedestrian (people / 12hours)

Cross

Down the road

1

Jl. Paledang

350

412

2

Jl. K.H. Z. Musthafa

4100

2234

3

Jl. Bantarpayung

841

902

4

Jl. Raya Cintaraja

648

639

5

Jl. Raya Singaparna

166

333

Source : Survey results, 2019

 

Recap of Survey Results

The survey results and calculations made can be used as a basis for planning pedestrian facilites in the form of sidewalks. Sidewalks can be directed to roads where there are more than 300 pedestrian volumes per 12 hours (06.00-18.00) and vehicle volume of over 1,000 vehicles per 12 hours (06.00-18.00).

To make it easier to read the survey results data, then created a recap of the survey results to determine the volume of vehicles and pedestrians on each road segment at the study site. Recap of survey results are as follows.

 

Table 5. Recap survey results

No.

Name of Street

Vehicle Volume

Pedestrian (people/12Hours)

(veh/12Hours)

Cross

Down The Road

Total

1

Jl. Paledang

5.483

350

412

762

2

Jl. K.H. Zaenal Musthafa

13.524

4.1

2.234

6.33

3

Jl. Bantarpayung

8.874

841

902

1.74

4

Jl. Raya Cintaraja

11.662

648

639

1.29

5

Jl. Raya Singaparna

22.661

166

333

499

Source : Survey Results and Calculation, 2019

 

Based on the results of the survey and the calculation, it can be seen that all roads in the study sites have a very large vehicle volume and almost all research sites have a vehicle volume of more than 1,000 kend./12 hours.

Neither with the volume of pedestrians can be seen in the above table an average of more than 300 pedestrians per 12 hours.

Based on the above description, it is necessary pedestrian facilities in the form of sidewalks on all roads in the research location because based on survey results and calculations, the sidewalks can be applied to all research sites.

 

 

Journal of Social Science | Jsss.co.id 103

 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


                  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Design of the sidewalk on Jl. Paledang

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Design of the sidewalk on Jl. Bantarpayung

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Design of the sidewalk on Jl.KH.Zaenal Musthafa

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Design of the sidewalk on Jl.Raya Cintaraja

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The cross section of the sidewalk on Jl. Singaparna

 

 

 

 

 


Desain Trotoar di Jl. Singaparna

 

Picture 2.      Proposed Sidewalk at Research Sites

 

Recommended Crossing Facilities

Ferry facilities are incomplete because the ferry facilities are no less important facilities in ensuring pedestrian safety. Recommended ferry facilities are determined based on the number of crossers and the volume of vehicles. Recommended ferry facilities can be seen in the table below.

 

 

Table 6. Recommended Cross Facilities

Nama Jalan

P

V

PV2

Rekomendation

 

Jl. Paledang

40

645

16.641.000

Zebra Cross

Jl. K.H. Zaenal Musthafa

468

1591

1.184.639.508

Pelican Crossing

Jl. Bantarpayung

96

1044

104.633.856

Zebra Cross

Jl. Raya Cintaraja

74

1372

139.296.416

Zebra Cross

Jl. Raya Singaparna

19

2666

135.043.564

Zebra Cross

Source : Results of data processing, 2019

 

Based on the results of data processing mentioned above, the majority of recommended crossing facilities is Zebra Cross. However, there is one segment that requires pelican crossing, which is on Jl. K. H. Zaenal Musthafa because of its high pedestrian activity and large vehicle volume.

 

Accesibility of Pedestrian Facility

The concept of pedestrian alignment theory is used in order to make pedestrian facility planning more convenient for its users.

* Indeks Konectivitas

   A number that indicate the level of connectivity in an area

 
 


Eksisting Condition

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Plan Kondition

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

From the results of the above analysis, it can be concluded connectivity of pedestrian integration between areas of pedestrian rise/pull in Tasikmalaya Regency education zone to be better than before. By connecting Jl. Paledang with Jl. Garut-Tasikmalaya, Jl. Bantar Payung- Jl.Garut-Tasikmalaya.

 

CONCLUSION

Based on the results of surveys and data processing that has been done, it can be seen that the research location in Tasikmalaya Regency has a large volume of vehicles and not a few heavy vehicles (buses and trucks) that cross the road on the study site. It is because the road segment at the research location is the main route for freight transport to travel from and to other cities/districts. Therefore, pedestrian facilities such as sidewalks and pedestrian facilities are necessary to separate vehicular traffic with pedestrian activity to minimize conflicts (vehicles and pedestrians). In one of the research sites, namely on Jl. K. H. Zaenal Musthafa needs a pelican crossing because of the huge volume of vehicles and the very high pedestrian volume because there are many travel rides for pedestrians at that location (schools, offices, and settlements).

 

REFERENCES

Direktorat Jenderal Bina Marga. (1995). Tata Cara Perencanaan Fasilitas Pejalan Kaki di Kawasan Perkotaan. Jakarta: Ditjen Bina Marga, Kementerian PU.

Direktorat Bina Sistem Lalu Lintas dan Angkutan Kota. (1999). Pedoman Perencanaan dan Pengoperasian Lalu Lintas di Wilayah Perkotaan. Jakarta: Direktorat BSTP, Ditjen Perhubungan Darat

Republik Indonesia. (2009). Undang-Undang No. 22 Tahun 2009 Tentang Lalu Lintas dan Angkutan Jalan. Jakarta.

Republik Indonesia. (2013). Instruksi Presiden No. 4 Tahun 2013 Tentang Program Dekade Aksi keselamatan Jalan. Jakarta.

Anggriani, N ( 2009). Pedestrian Ways Dalam Perancangan Kota. Klaten: Yayasan Humaniora

Ewing, R (2019). Pedestrian and Transit Oriented Design. Broche: Urban Land Institute

Journal of Social Science | Jsss.co.id 104

 
Nazir, M. (2005). Metodologi Penelitian. Bogor: Ghalia Indonesia.

Munawar, A (2004). Manajemen Lalu Lintas Perkotaan. Jogjakarta: Beta Offset

Nacto (2013). Urban Street Design Guide. Washington: IslandPress

Tanan, N (2011). Fasilitas Pejalan Kaki. Bandung: Pusjatan

 


Journal of Social Science | Jsss.co.id 105