Agnesia Benedictta C. Tewu,
Itje Pangkey, Marthinus Mandagi
Universitas Negeri
Manado, Tondano Barat, Minahasa
95615, Indonesia
Email: [email protected]
|
ARTICLE INFO |
ABSTRACT |
|
Date received : 13-10-2021 Revision date : 2-11-2021 Date
received : 12-11-2021 |
This study aims to analyze the accountability of the general election
administration in the Minahasa Regency. This research uses qualitative
methods, direct research to data sources and researchers are the key
instruments. Qualitative research emphasizes the process of searching for the
meaning behind the phenomena that arise in research with the aim that the
problems studied are more in-depth, natural, and as they are without
interference from researchers. From the results of the study, it was found
that accountability is an ethical concept that is close to government public
administration (government executive institutions, parliamentary legislative
institutions, and judicial institutions) this is often used synonymously with
concepts such as accountability, the ability to provide answers
(answerability) that can be blamed (blameworthiness) and which have liability,
including other terms that have no connection with the hope of being able to
explain part of one aspect of public administration. The technical guidance
received by PPS and KPPS is just a matter of election procedures. Submission
of other information to voters is still carried out directly by the KPU and
its implementation is not too optimal and not yet accountable, where the
limitations of KPU members are not good in quantity. Then for suggestions to
make it even better, it is recommended that the implementation of the
Regional Election for the Regional Head Election of the Minahasa Regency KPUD
should be more accountable from the preparation stage to the announcement
stage of the Pilkada winner. |
|
Keywords: Accountability; Development; Implementation; General election |
Introduction
Administration
In the context of governance, accountability is a prerequisite for the creation
of good, democratic, and trustworthy governance (Raba, 2006).
In this concept, accountability is often associated with a car or resource
management that has been given and controlled by an institution, or individual
to achieve goals through a medium in the form of periodic performance
accountability reports (Wiliam, 2015).
One
thing that cannot be separated from the implementation of good governance is
the concept related to its characterization, including transparency,
responsiveness, consensus orientation, equity, efficiency, effectiveness, and
accountability (Zeyn, 2014).
From these characteristics, there are three important aspects of accountability,
namely the realization of transparency, efficiency, and effectiveness. Accountability
is the provision of information and disclosure of activities and performance to
interested parties. Accountability according to (Agung, 2020)
is a form of obligation to account for the success or failure of the
implementation of the organization's mission in achieving predetermined goals
and targets, through a medium of accountability that is carried out
periodically.
Furthermore,
Stoker (1998:82) suggests that accountability is an effort to account for the
implementation of duties and authorities by public officials or by government
administrators (Chhotray & Stoker, 2009).
Therefore, every government administrator in carrying out his various duties
and authorities must prioritize accountability so that the rights, obligations,
actions, expertise, and even time spent in public must be accountable so that
good governance will be realized.
Public
accountability is the government's responsibility to the community related to
the activities and activities that are its responsibility through the
presentation of financial statements, where the public has the right and
authority to ask for accountability (Fernando, Loke, & Rahayu, 2011).
General
elections as a means of implementing people's sovereignty in Indonesia are
carried out by the General Election Commission (KPU) (ZALUKHU, 2021).
Normatively, the existence of the KPU is regulated in Article 22E paragraph (5)
1945 which states that the election is carried out by a General Election
Commission. The General Election Commission (KPU) is a national, permanent, and
independent election organizing body. KPU as the organizer of the election and
as mandated in Law Number 07 of 20017 concerning General Election Organizers in
organizing the General Election is committed and guided by the principles of
independence, honesty, fairness, legal certainty, orderliness, public interest,
openness, proportionality, professionalism, accountability, efficiency, and
effectiveness (Nengsih, 2019).
Considering that the KPU's task is to organize elections for members of the
House of Representatives (DPR), members of the People's Representative Council (DPD),
Members of Regional People's Representatives (DPRD) as well as elections for
President and Vice President which are held directly, publicly, freely,
confidentially, honestly and fairly (Suantara, 2021).
In
addition to this task, it also carries out the implementation of Regional Head
Elections (Pemilukada), namely to elect the Governor
and Deputy Governor, Regent and Deputy Regent, Mayor and Deputy Mayor. To carry
out these tasks, the Provincial KPU and Regency/Municipal KPU were also formed.
Participants in Indonesia's five-year democracy cannot be separated from
various kinds of problems that have always been a polemic in this country (Subiakto, 2015).
The phenomenon of the White Group, the right to vote is a right that should not
be wasted. Because these rights can determine the fate of the State of
Indonesia for the next 5 years. But until now many people have not exercised
their right to vote. They are referred to as the White Group or people who do not
vote during elections. Many factors can cause the white group, ranging from
individual factors and factors from not knowing the existing legislative
candidates, to the many jobs that make people do not have time to go to polling
stations. From the government, such as the lack of socialization carried out so
that many people do not understand to vote, especially people who are in remote
or remote areas.
From
the observations of researchers related to the Regional Head Election in 2018,
there were problems at the stage of the Regional Head General Election such as
in determining the Permanent Voter List (DPT) where DP4 was based on the
Identity Card (KTP-el). Furthermore, there are public complaints where many
residents are not registered as voters even though they have long lived in Minahasa Regency.
The
next problem that has become phenomenal is that the basic rules that refer to
Law Number 7 of 2017 concerning General Elections Article 240 point G, which
should be the basis of PKPU number 2 of 2018 are issued, still need to be
interpreted explicitly in the determination of the Permanent Candidate List (AMANDE, 2018).
Normatively in the Regional Head Elections in Indonesia, in Article 2 of Law
number 07 of 2017 concerning the Implementation of Elections, there are at
least 3 indicators that have public accountability for organizers, namely: (1)
that each organizer (KPU) must be independent, honest, fair, legal certainty,
orderly organizers of the Owners, prioritizing public and open interests; must
be professional, proportional, accountable, efficient and effective; (2) The
Operator must be independent of any party about its duties and implementation
and authority; (3) The organizers must consistently enforce the election law
regulations.
From
the problems above, the researcher is interested in researching the
Administrative Accountability of the Regional General Election Commission (PUD)
of the Minahasa Regency (Study on the 2018 Minahasa Regency Head Election). The formulation of the
problem in this research is: how is the level of accountability in the
administration of the Regional General Election Commission (KPUD) in the
implementation of the General Election in Minahasa Regency?.
Method
The
method used in this research is qualitative. Where Bogdan and Biklen (Astuti, Prawoto, Irawan, Sugiono, & Saleh, 2019)
suggest that qualitative research is carried out in natural conditions, (as
opposed to an experiment), directly to the data source and the researcher is
the key instrument. Qualitative research emphasizes the process of searching
for the meaning behind the phenomena that arise in research with the aim that the
problems studied are more in-depth, natural, and as they are without
interference from researchers.
The
focus of this research is related to the formulation of research problems and
the position of focus is temporary because it can change when the research is
conducted. It is said to be a temporary focus because at first, it is still
general and vague, it will become clearer and get focus after the researcher is
in the field (G�stavsd�ttir, n.d.).
The main data sources in qualitative research are words and actions, the rest
are additional data such as other documents. The main instrument in qualitative
research is the researcher himself, (Sugiyono, 2013)
suggests that in collecting data the researcher must actively engage himself in
the field. By using tools such as photos, field notes, tape recorders, and
interview guidelines.
Minahasa Regency has an area of
121,043.31 ha consisting of 25 sub-districts. Tombariri/East
Tombariri District. has the largest area of
15,840,89 ha while Kawangkoan District
has the smallest area of 1,325,21 ha. Minahasa
Regency is one of the areas in North Sulawesi. The location of this area
according to latitude and longitude is: 1o22' 44''N/ 124o 33' 52'' east
longitude to 1o 01' 11'' north longitude/ 124o 54' 45'' east longitude to 125o
04' 21''E/1o 20' 25'' LU. Minahasa Regency is
generally hilly, mountainous, and a rather broad plain, only around Lake Tondano. These plains are found in the Tondano,
Remboken, Tommaso, Langowan,
and Kakas areas. Slopes vary from flat to very steep.
Very steep slopes are found in Kombi District, Kakas District, and South Langowan District.
A.
Minahasa Regency Map

The total area of
Minahasa Regency is 121,041.30 ha, but some
areas are not productive of 29,103 ha consisting of a forest area of
14,816.00 ha, a residential area of 6,344.11 ha, a
coastal border area of 759.00 ha, a river border area of
3,562.00 ha, area around lakes/dams covering 418.00 ha, area
around springs 6.40 ha, green open space area of 353.00 ha, and
area of nature reserves, nature conservation and cultural
heritage covering 2,845,00 ha. So that the production area is 87.4911 ha.
B.
Election Overview
In the implementation
of general elections (elections) to elect leaders of the state, province,
district, city, and people's representatives, of course, an election management
institution is needed. In Indonesia, the institution responsible for organizing
general elections is the General Elections Commission. The General Election
Commission is a state institution that is national and independent to organize
General Elections in Indonesia.
Based on the provisions
of Article 1 point 9 of Law Number 1 of 2015 as amended several times, most
recently by Law Number 10 of 2016, the Minahasa
Regency KPU is the General Elections Organizing Agency that is given the task
of holding the Election of Regents and Deputy Regents in Minahasa
Regency which included in the third wave of the 2018 Simultaneous Regional
Elections.
Selection Stage
Based on KPU
Regulation Number 1 of 2017 concerning Stages, Programs and Schedule for the
Election of Governor and Deputy Governor, Regent and Deputy Regent, and/or
Mayor and Deputy Mayor, as amended by General Election Commission Regulation
Number 2 of 2018, as well as Election Commission Decree General Minahasa Regency Number 33/PP.02.3-Kb/KPU-Kab/7102/VII/2017 concerning Technical Guidelines for Stages,
Programs, and Schedules for Organizing the Election of Regents and Deputy
Regents of Minahasa Regency in 2018.
C.
Research result
Accountability is an
ethical concept that is close to government Public
administration (government executive agencies, parliamentary legislative institutions,
and judicial institutions of the Judiciary) it is often used synonymously with
concepts such as accountability, the ability to provide answers, which can
Blameworthiness and liability, including other terms that have relevance in the
hope of explaining some or one aspect of public administration.
Elections in the form
of democracy with an important aspect to be carried out democratically by all
related communities, but not every election is said to be democratic, because democratic
elections are not just symbols or symbols, but elections that must be carried
out periodically, definitively, inclusively, and competitively in determine
government. The legitimacy of the power of a certain person or political party
is not obtained using violence. As a form of implementation of democracy, the
next general election serves as a forum that screens candidates for people's
representatives or state leaders who have the capacity and capability to be
able to act on behalf of the people. Apart from being a forum that filters
people's representatives or national leaders, general elections are also
related to the principle of the rule of law, because through elections, the
people can choose their representatives who have the right to create legal
products and carry out supervision or implementation of the people's will outlined by the representatives. - representatives of the
people. However, the victory occurred because the majority of the people's
votes were obtained through fair elections. Democracy provides space for
individual freedom. Elections in this context mean that conflicts that occur
during the electoral process are resolved through democratic institutions (Sayuti, Ulum, & Kusnadi, 2018).
In the following, the
researcher asked some questions to informants from PPS members in the 2018
regional head election, KPPS Kelurahan, as well as
the Head of the field of data determination and services of the Capital
Service. Initially, the researcher asked whether there was a socialization
process for voters regarding voter participation and election procedures?
Informant "JD" answered:
For PPS Kelurahan only receive instructions from the KPU because
the process of socialization to voters is all carried out by the KPU. The
election procedure in the kelurahan is usually
carried out during mourning activities or community organization events (artisan)
and is carried out by the Kelurahan PPS. (January
2020 interview).
To make the election
of the Regent and Deputy Regent of Minahasa
successful in 2018, according to the stages, programs, and schedules that have
been set by KPU regulation number 1 of 2017. As amended by KPU regulation
number 2 of 2018, it will be held on 27 June 2018, KPU Minahasa
continues to social programs and activities to the community, including
inviting all people who are scattered in various communities and the kelurahan. Furthermore, with the same question related to
the process of socialization to voters regarding voter participation and
election procedures, the informant "MK" answered:
In general election
socialization activities related to voter participation, the communication
process that takes place is usually carried out using lectures and dialogues,
but can also be carried out in worship columns and churches and aims to convey
messages and information to make it easier for the public to understand.
(Interview January 2020).
While the informant
"LM" answered "Less Know". Through several socialization
bases in the community that was conveyed according to the informants above,
they received such an enthusiastic response from the community. With this socialization,
the KPU also encountered several obstacles in the southern Tondano
area, namely the position of the Manado University campus which was occupied by
so many students, in this case, Unima students who
had graduated status but were still registered in the DPT records in the
southern Tondano area.
Socialization is part
of the process of learning about culture about the social system. In this
process, an individual from childhood to old age learns patterns of thinking in
acting and interacting with all kinds of individuals around him who occupy
various social roles that exist in everyday life. About the socialization
process in every Pilkada activity in Minahasa Regency, the definition of the concept of
socialization above seems still relevant to be used as a reference basis. At
least to explain the relationship between socialization as a social process,
and learning about the culture as a concept (cultural learning process). To
realize the 2018 Minahasa elections that are credible
and safe, the Minahasa Regency KPU through the Minahasa Regency regional coordinator has carried out
socialization for community leaders and religious leaders in various
sub-districts in Minahasa, and was also attended by
PPK, resource persons for the Minahasa KPU chairman
and the Minahasa Police Chief.
Coordination related
to updating data and compiling voter lists as well as evaluation in the context
of the 2018 Minahasa Regent and Deputy Regent
elections is one of the efforts to uniform perception and understanding of
substance, as well as to prepare data and documents needed in decision making.
The Minahasa Regency KPU has carried out several
activities with the Minahasa Regency Population and
Civil Registration Office, in addition to building harmonization and synergy in
welcoming the 2018 Minahasa Pilkada
as well as taking steps to optimize the process of updating data and compiling
the voter list.
In the successful
election of the Regent and Deputy Regent of Minahasa
in 2018, specifically related to updating data and compiling the voter list as
stated in the letter from the chairman of the Minahasa
Regency KPU number 332/KPU-Min-023.436239/XI/2017 dated November 13, 2017,
regarding the request for a hearing, the Minahasa
Regency KPU together The Minahasa Regency Disdukcapil held a meeting and agreed to cooperate on the
condition that voters must have an EL-KTP as stipulated in KPU regulation
number 2 of 2017, including socializing it to the Minahasa
community, according to the results of coordination on Wednesday 15 November
2017, which took place at the office Disdukcapil Minahasa Regency. The following is the A.C-KWK data
submitted to the Minahasa Regency Disdukcapil
totaling 27,852 voters with the following details:
D.
AC-KWK data according to the results of DPS
determination.
|
Laki-Laki |
|
|
|
Perempuan |

The data referred to above has been verified
by the Disdukcapil of Minahasa
Regency, with the result that of the 27,829 voters listed in the A.C-KWK, there
were only 9,284 registered voters and 18,545 voters who were not recorded in
the Minahasa Regency population database. The number
of voters recorded in the Minahasa Regency population
database as well as data from the Minahasa Regency Disdukcapil has been followed up in a plenary meeting of
discussion and determination of the Minahasa Regency
DPSHP which is carried out in stages.
The Open Plenary Meeting for the
Recapitulation of the Corrected Temporary Voter List (DPSHP) and the
determination of the DPT was closed on Saturday, April 21, 2018, with the
result that the Minahasa Regency DPT was set at
251,140 voters consisting of 126,714 male voters and 124,426 female voters
spread across the country. 578 TPS in 270 villages/kelurahan.
Conclusion
From the
results of the research carried out it can be concluded that:1). The technical
guidance received by PPS and KPPS is just a matter of election procedures.
Submission of other information for voters is still carried out directly by the
KPU and in its implementation, it is not too optimal and not yet accountable,
where the limitations of KPU members are not good in quantity. 2). There is no
complete trust given by KPU to PPS and KPPS in disseminating the stages of
election and other important information related to the Election of Regional
Heads. 3). PPS in Kelurahan only receive instructions
from the KPU and all of the socialization processes are carried out by the KPU.
The
socialization of the procedures for the election of regional heads to the
community in Kelurahan-Kelurahan carried out by the
KPU was carried out during mourning worship activities and community organization
events (arisan).
References
Agung, Mulyo. (2020). The Effect of Financial Reporting
Quality on Regional Governments� Performance Accountability. KnE Social
Sciences, 694�701.Google Scholar
AMANDE, Yuantoni Fidelico Brucel. (2018). Problematika
Pemberhentian Antar Waktu (Paw) Anggota Dprd Kabupaten/Kota Dalam Undang-Undang
Nomor 17 Tahun 2014 Tentang MPR, DPR, DPD & DPRD. Google Scholar
Astuti, Murti, Prawoto, Pratikto, Irawan, Yudy Surya,
Sugiono, Sugiono, & Saleh, S. M. (2019). The Role of the University in the
Implementation of Eco-Innovation at the Creative Industry Center of Natural
Stone Crafts. International Journal of Integrated Engineering, 11(5),
58�65. Google Scholar
Chhotray, Vasudha, & Stoker, Gerry. (2009). Governance
and International Relations. In Governance Theory and Practice (pp. 76�96).
Springer. Google Scholar
Fernando, Niroshinie, Loke, Seng W., & Rahayu, Wenny.
(2011). Dynamic mobile cloud computing: Ad hoc and opportunistic job sharing. 2011
Fourth IEEE International Conference on Utility and Cloud Computing, 281�286.
IEEE. Google Scholar
G�stavsd�ttir, Ger�ur. (n.d.). �j�nusta vi� b�rn og
ungmenni � �j�nustumi�st��. Sam��tting �j�nustu. Google Scholar
Nengsih, Neng Suryanti. (2019). Integritas KPU dan Pemilihan
Umum. JURNAL ILMU SOSIAL DAN ILMU POLITIK, 1(1), 51�61.Google Scholar
Raba, Manggaukang. (2006). Akuntabilitas konsep dan
Implementasi (Vol. 1). UMMPress. Google Scholar
Sayuti, Achmad, Ulum, Bahrul, & Kusnadi, Dedek. (2018). Netralisasi
Komisi Pemilihan Umum (Kpu) Dalam Penyelenggaraan Pemilu Menurut Undang Undang
Nomor 7 Tahun 2017. UIN Sulthan Thaha Saifuddin Jambi. Google Scholar
Suantara, I. Gede. (2021). Kewenangan Badan Pengawas Pemilu
(Bawaslu) Menganulir Peraturan Yang Dibuat Oleh Komisi Pemilihan Umum (Kpu)
Dalam Penyelenggaraan Pemilihan Umum. Privatelaw, 1(1). Google Scholar
Subiakto, Henry. (2015). Komunikasi politik, media, dan
demokrasi. Prenada Media. Google Scholar
Sugiyono, Dr. (2013). Metode penelitian pendidikan
pendekatan kuantitatif, kualitatif dan R&D. Google Scholar
Wiliam, Glant. (2015). Analisa Manajemen dan Resolusi Konflik
Agama: Studi Kasus HKBP (Huria Kristen Batak Protestan) Pondok Timur Indah,
Kota Bekasi Tahun 2010-2014. Bakrie University. Google Scholar
Zalukhu, Nestrorius Nefrans. (2021). Peranan Komisi Pemilihan
Umum (Kpu) Dalam Penyelenggaraan Pemilihan Kepala Daerah Untuk Meningkatkan
Partisipasi Politik Masyarakat (Studi Kasus Pilkada Wali Kota Medan Tahun 2020). Google Scholar
Zeyn, Elvira. (2014). Pengaruh penerapan good governance dan
standar akuntansi pemerintahan terhadap akuntabilitas keuangan. Trikonomika
Journal, 10(1), 52�62. Google Scholar
|
Copyright holder: Agnesia Benedictta C. Tewu, Itje Pangkey, Marthinus Mandagi (2021) |
|
First publication right: |
|
This article is licensed under: |