Ema Sumiarti, Rusijono,
Andi Mariono
Educational Technology Study Program, Surabaya
State University, Indonesia
Surabaya State University, Indonesia
Surabaya State University, Indonesia
Email: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
|
ARTICLE INFO |
ABSTRACT |
|
Received
� 23 Juny 2021 Revision 1 July 2021 Approved 10 July 2021 |
The important role of policy makers is to develop and improve program
implementation. The purpose of the study in general is to evaluate the
supporting components of the implementation of online learning which include
learning facilities at home and parents' attention in learning, the input
component of students' initial abilities, and the process components of
activeness following online learning in relation to increasing the competence
of SMK students in Malang and Batu. The research design uses
evaluation research. The research sample involved 240 students of the
multimedia expertise program at SMKN 4, 5, 11 Malang City and SMKN 3 Batu.
The data analysis technique used in this research was SEM (Structural
Equation Modeling) and LISREL. The results of this study are, 1) learning
facilities at home have a direct effect on students' initial abilities,
student activity. 2) parents' attention in learning has a direct effect on
students' initial ability and student competence, and has an indirect effect
on student learning activeness and competence. |
|
Keywords: program evaluation online learning student competence SMK |
INTRODUCTION
Education
was also affected by the Industrial Revolution 4.0. Especially vocational
education. This is because SMK aims to prepare students to become more
productive individuals. To produce graduates who are able to work
independently, fill job vacancies that are a dream in the business and
industrial world, as middle-level workers who have the competencies and skills
they choose.
Every
institution that provides vocational education must be committed to making its
graduates able to work in the field of expertise being studied. The real impact
on vocational education is the demand for changes in student competencies and
learning strategies adapted to the needs of the 21st century.
Vocational
Education Has Several Important Aspects That Are Required, Vocational Education
Needs To Contribute To Students In The Aspects Of Social, Cultural And Economic
Development Of Society That Are Currently Developing. Leads To An Understanding
Of Scientific Aspects And Technology That Is Currently Developing In The
Community. Currently There Are Around 13,900 Smks Managed Privately And 3,400
Are Managed By The State. This Shows That Smk Is Currently Experiencing An
Explosive Growth In Terms Of Number. However, The Problem Is That The
Fulfillment Of Smk Quality Standards Has Not Been Evenly Distributed Because
The Concentration Is Only For Building The Physical Sector, Not Accompanied By
Good Quality Assurance Efforts. In The Data From The Statistical Calculation
Results Of Vocational Schools In East Java For The 2017/2018 School Year, The
Dropout Rate For State and Private Vocational High Schools reached 73,888
students with a graduation rate of State and Private Vocational High Schools of
13,665 students who had not passed from SMK.
To
Improve The Quality Of Education Is One Of The Restoration Efforts In The
Education Sector By The Ministry Of Education And Culture. Thus, At This Time
Education Must Shift To Improving Quality Based On Online Systems. Almost All
Human Life Today Is Very Dependent On The Use Of Online Media, So It Is
Inevitable For The World Of Education To Also Take Advantage Of The Online
System. The Challenge Is To Create An Online Education System That Can
Encourage Quality Improvement Towards Quality Education And Quality Of
Vocational High School Graduates.
The
Ministry Of Education And Culture, And The East Java Provincial Education
Office Are Aggressively Launching Online Learning, One Of Which Is The Online
Learning Program Implemented By Seamolec Through Smk To Improve The Competence
Of Vocational Students, Learning Using Web Applications Is A Development Of
Existing Online Learning Models. In The Implementation Of Online Learning
Programs That Have Been Implemented For Several Years Up To The Development Of
Various Online Learning Models, It Is Necessary To Evaluate The Implementation
Of Online Learning Programs To See The Effectiveness Of Program Implementation
In Increasing Student Competence.
A
program to achieve the goals, that have been planned from the start. (Arikunto & Jabar, 2004)
explains that the program is a system, and the system
itself is a single program of various program components that are interconnected
and work together with one another to achieve the goals that have been set
early on in the system. (Fink, 1995) explains that the program is a systematic effort to achieve a previously
planned goal. A similar opinion is also explained by (Leonard, 1984) that a program is a set of activities or facilities designed to achieve a
goal. Referring to this opinion, the online learning program is a system that
consists of a single program and the supporting components of the program are
intertwined with each other to work together between components to achieve
program objectives, namely increasing student competence.
In
implementing the online learning program at SMK, there are several elements
that support each other between learning facilities at home such as study
rooms, learning support furniture, learning aids and learning resources,
parents' attention in learning (guiding, supervising, motivating and fulfilling
children's needs in the process. learning), the initial abilities of students,
the activeness of students in participating in online learning, accurate data
has not been found.� In order to achieve
maximum learning outcomes, there are several variables that can support the
quality of online learning, including learning facilities at home, and parents'
attention in learning. Learning facilities are all equipment, materials, and
furniture that are used directly in learning activities at
(Bafadal, 2004). It can be said that learning facilities are tools that more or less
influence the learning process which may have an impact on student achievement.
Meanwhile, according to (Gie, 2004)
"the availability of adequate learning facilities,
such as a good study room, appropriate study furniture, efficient learning
equipment can support good learning continuity".
Parents'
attention in learning towards students has a very important role in achieving
maximum student achievement. So that in the implementation of online learning
the role of parents is related to the level of competence of students. (Bimo Walgito, 2004)
defines attention, as an activity related to the
selection of a stimulus that comes from the environment. According to (Dalyono, 2009) and (Slameto, 2010) the form of parental attention, students get supervision in learning which
is very necessary to ensure that what the child does does not deviate from
rules or things that are outside the learning objectives. Parental supervision
can also be interpreted as the supervision of all activities carried out by
children, either directly or indirectly. Parents can be father/mother, guardian
of students or people who are
responsible for students while participating in learning. The learning process
according to (Bandura, 1977)
is influenced by three things, namely behavior,
cognitive, and environment. So that environmental support factors are very
influential on cognitive and vice versa. In its implementation, to identify the
online learning program activities that will be achieved, it is also necessary
to observe several indicators of learning facilities at home with
sub-indicators (1) space or learning space at home, including space for
learning, space size, color, ventilation and lighting. study rooms, (2)
learning furniture at home, sub-indicators include places to sit and write,
study lamps, conditions for sitting and writing, bookshelves and air
conditioners, (3) learning aids include office stationery, wifi/modem, internet
quota, stability of electric power and laptops/smartphones, and (4) learning resources
including textbooks, social media, printed/electronic media.
In
addition, what needs to be observed is the parents' attention in learning, namely
the awareness of parents to care for their children, especially in providing
and fulfilling their children's needs in learning both in terms of emotion and
material. Parents' attention in learning includes children being guided in
learning, children are supervised in the learning process, children are
motivated in learning and their needs are met in learning.
In
order to achieve the goals that were planned from the start, online learning
must be evaluated. As above, (Arikunto & Jabar, 2004)
explains that the program is a system, and the system itself is a single
program of various program components that are interconnected and work together
with each other to achieve the goals that have been set from the start in the
system. In online learning programs, there is a need for program evaluation
that aims to assist administrators or policy makers in making decisions.
Program evaluation is used to determine whether the objectives are achieved as
expected.
Evaluation
has an important role to play in stimulating and planning improvement changes. (Worthen & Sanders, 1973)
describe program evaluation as a process of identifying and gathering
information to assist decision makers in choosing decisions from a number of
available decision alternatives. According to (Stufflebeam & Shinkfield, 2012)
states that, the CIPP approach is based on the view that the most important
purpose of evaluation is not to prove but improve. The online learning program
is a learning system consisting of various components that are interrelated
with one another in implementation to achieve predetermined goals from the
start. In evaluating this online learning program, it carries out a series of
systematic activities to collect data and information related to the program
components as input for decision makers on the online learning program.
To
evaluate the program of online learning program activities that will help
policy makers in developing and improving program implementation. As explained
by Stufflebeam, the most important goal in an
evaluation is improvement. This learning program is a system that consists of
various components in the implementation of the system to achieve goals. Program
improvement in its implementation is to improve the components in the program.
The program evaluation model used is the CIPP (Context, Input, Process,
Product) model because the direction of the evaluation of this model is to
improve the online learning system. Guidance for the implementation of individual
studies is not a major concern, but is more concentrated on providing
continuous evaluation services to decision makers in institutions. So that the
emphasis of the CIPP model evaluation is to help maintain and improve the
quality of institutional operations. This online learning program evaluation
research uses the CIPP Model evaluation because the CIPP model has a
comprehensive approach to evaluation, aims to provide a very detailed and broad
picture of an activity program, starting from its context to its implementation
process. So it is very good at helping make
improvements during the program, as well as providing final information.
Based
on the background, the formulation of the research problems are:
1) Do learning facilities at home affect student competencies? 2) Does the
attention of parents in learning affect student competence? Judging from the
problem formulation, the aim of the research in general is to evaluate the
components of the implementation of online learning programs in order to improve
the quality of the implementation of online learning programs in increasing the
competence of vocational students in the Malang and Batu Regional Education
Office Branches.
The
research objective was to explain the effect of home learning facilities, and
the influence of parental attention. By evaluating the implementation of online
learning programs, it is hoped that the components that have a high role in the
implementation of online learning can be identified in improving the competence
of vocational students.
METHOD
The
subjects of this study were students at State Vocational High Schools with
multimedia expertise programs in the Regional Education Office of Malang and
Batu City. For groups or clusters of multimedia expertise programs taken as samples
in this study as many as 240 students from SMKN 4, SMKN 5, SMKN 11 Malang City
and SMKN 3 Kota Batu.
In
this research, the approach taken is
to use an evaluation model with the CIPP model. CIPP evaluation dimensions used
are context, input, process, and product. The data collection techniques used
were, 1) Documentation, 2) Questionnaires, and 3) Test. Meanwhile, the
instruments in the study were documentation of a home study facility
questionnaire, a questionnaire for parents' attention. The data analysis
technique used has the suitability of the online learning program policy
evaluation model in improving the competence of vocational school students in
the Malang and Batu Regional Education Office Branches with empirical data is a
structural equation model using the assistance of Linear Structural
Relationship (LISREL) software. The determination of this analysis technique is
based on several considerations. First, this technique can be used to test the
suitability of the relationship model that has been developed based on theory
with empirical data. Second, LISREL is the most precise technique compared to
other multivariate analysis techniques. In accordance with the considerations
used in determining the analysis technique above, the objectives to be achieved
from this analysis are: 1) testing the suitability of the Hypothetical Model
with Empirical Data. The criteria used to determine the suitability of a
hypothetical model with empirical data are: λ2 (Chi-Square), Goodness of
Fit Index (GFI), and Root Mean Square Residual (RMR). The hypothetical model
developed in this study is presented covering 2 variables, namely learning
facilities at home, and parents' attention in learning in online learning. In
addition to describing the structural relationship between variables, it also
describes the measurement model for each variable by developing the observed
variables or indicators of each variable. There are 3 types of relationships
analyzed, namely: direct effect, indirect effect, and total effect. It can be
seen from the t value of each gamma coefficient (γ), in determining the
significance of the direct effect of the variable. To determine the
significance of the overall effect and the indirect effect of the variable, it
is seen from the t value of each coefficient of the overall effect and indirect
effect. The level of significance used in this analysis is 0.05.
A. Result
In accordance
with the research objectives, there are 2 (two) variables in this study, namely
Home Study Facilities / FBR, and Parents' Attention in Learning / POR, and
variable Y (Student Competence / KOMP). Based on the data obtained, the
learning facilities at home include a room or a place to study at home,
furniture to support learning at home, learning aids, and learning resources. Research
and measurement of the variables in question were carried out using a
questionnaire method and an instrument in the form of a questionnaire
distributed to respondents consisting of 20 (twenty) closed question items. Each
question item provides four alternative answers. The score ranges for each item
1 to 4, with a maximum score of 80 and a minimum score of 20.
From the
results of data collection, a frequency distribution table and pie chart can be
drawn up as follows:
Table 1
Frequency Distribution
of Home Study Facilities
|
Interval |
Categories |
F |
Distribution |
|||
|
% f |
% cumulative |
|||||
|
66 |
- |
80 |
Very Good |
118 |
49,17 |
49,17 |
|
51 |
- |
65 |
Good |
77 |
32,08 |
81,25 |
|
36 |
- |
50 |
Enough |
28 |
11,67 |
92,92 |
|
20 |
- |
35 |
Less |
17 |
7,08 |
100 |
|
Total |
|
240 |
100 |
|
||
Source: Processed data

Figure 1.
Diagram of Study Facilities at Home
Most of the students who were the respondents in this study were in the
very good category. Meanwhile, the categories of good, moderate, and poor are
under them sequentially.
In the variable of parental attention in learning, the indicators measured
are children being guided in learning, children are supervised in the learning
process, children are motivated in learning, and children have their needs met
in learning. Research and measurement of the variables in question were carried
out using a questionnaire method and an instrument in the form of a
questionnaire distributed to respondents consisting of 31 closed questions.
Each question item provides 4 alternative answers. The score range for each item
1 to 4. Based on this, the maximum score for measuring the variable parents'
attention in learning is 124 and the minimum score is 31. From the results of
data collection, a frequency distribution table and pie chart can be compiled
as follows:
Table 2
Frequency Distribution of
Parents' Attention in Learning
|
Interval |
Categories |
Distribution |
||||
|
F |
% f |
% cumulative |
||||
|
102 |
- |
124 |
Very Good |
137 |
57,08 |
57,08 |
|
78 |
- |
101 |
Good |
56 |
23,33 |
80,42 |
|
54 |
- |
77 |
Enough |
30 |
12,50 |
92,92 |
|
31 |
- |
53 |
Less |
17 |
7,08 |
100 |
|
Total |
240 |
100 |
|
|||
Source: Processed data

Figure 2.
Diagram of Parents' Attention in Learning
Most of the students who were the respondents in this study were in the
very good category, followed by the good category, only the less category in
order.
B. Discussion
1. Home learning facilities affect student competence
The components of
learning facilities at home affect the initial ability of vocational students
in the field of multimedia expertise in the Regional Education Office of Malang
and Batu City. Students who have high initial abilities or are competent as
much as 99.59%. After testing and analysis, it was found that the direct effect
of home learning facilities was significant on the initial ability of
vocational students in the field of multimedia expertise with a direct effect
coefficient of 0.41. So, learning facilities at home have a direct effect on
the initial abilities of vocational school students in the Regional Education
Office of Malang and Batu. Also obtained data, learning facilities at home have
a significant effect of 0.20 on student activeness in online learning. With
learning facilities at home learning aids include learning stationery, wifi/modem, internet package quotas, stability of electric
power, computers, smartphones and learning resources, students can smoothly and
easily follow online learning. As (Asma, 2013) states, there is an
influence between the availability of learning facilities and student learning
activities.
From the student
data as many as 240 respondents after testing and data analysis showed that the
results of students who took online learning were presented in Figure 5.To be able to participate in the learning process and
master the material of printing graphic design, 2 and 3 dimensional animation
as well as creative and entrepreneurial products students must actively participate
learning so there is no distribution of student data who are not active in
participating in online learning . Based on the results of hypothesis testing and data analysis of this study, it
was found that learning facilities at home had a significant effect on student
activity in participating in online learning with a value of nilai (gamma) of 0.30.
The results of
this research
also
show that students who do not get good home study facilities, the scores of
graphic design, 2 and 3 dimensional animation, as well
as creative and entrepreneurial products are quite high. In the study, the
results of data analysis showed that the indirect effect of home learning facilities
on students 'activeness in participating in online learning through students'
initial abilities with an indirect effect coefficient of 0.31 and a value of
γ (gamma) of 0.27. Although in this study it shows that learning
facilities at home do not have a direct effect on student competence but have
an indirect effect on student competence with an indirect effect coefficient of
0.35 and a value of γ (gamma) of 0.22.
The results of the
research test showed that by getting parents' attention in learning,
students had high initial abilities, so that parents' attention in learning had
a positive effect on student competence with a t-value of 5.04 and a value of
γ (gamma) of 0.47. As explained by Syansudin in (Usman, 2010), the provision of
guidance, supervision and motivation in children aims to make children more
focused in solving task problems in learning. From the data analysis, it was
found that the coefficient of direct influence of the variable parental
attention in learning on student competence was not significant with a γ
(gamma) value of 0.15. So that the attention of parents in learning does not
have a direct effect on student competence. After analyzing the data, it was
found that the coefficient of direct influence between the variables of
parents' attention in learning to the significant competency variable was 0.43
with a value of γ (gamma) 0.34. The results of hypothesis testing show that
parents' attention in learning has a significant effect on student competence.
Parents' attention
has no direct effect on student competence with a value of γ (gamma) 0.15.
The lower the attention of people, the lower the competence of students. In
this study, the indicators are the same as previous studies but the
sub-indicators are different according to the respondents of vocational
students and online learning models. In previous studies, respondents were not
vocational high school students. The conditions in learning are also different
in face-to-face learning and not at the vocational school level, parents can
accompany and guide their children in learning. Meanwhile, people in vocational
schools sometimes do not understand multimedia subjects and in the online
learning model students must actively participate in learning in order to
understand and follow the material.
Parents' attention
in learning has an indirect effect on student competence with a value of γ
(gamma) of 0.47 and a coefficient of indirect influence of 0.38. As explained,
students do not get parental guidance, supervision and reward, they will still
be competent. But parents' attention in learning has an indirect effect on student
competence in taking online lessons. (Astuti, 2015) said there was a
positive influence between initial ability and interest in learning with
learning achievement. Requirements for students to get the title of competent
in the field of multimedia expertise, students must pass a competency test.
Parents are always concerned about things that have to do with learning
outcomes. To achieve good learning outcomes in the field of multimedia expertise
through online learning, students must be competent. So that
parents will pay attention, supervise and motivate their children to
always actively follow the learning. In this study, it is shown by the results
of hypothesis testing that parents' attention in learning has an indirect
effect on student competence with the indirect effect coefficient of γ
(gamma) value of 0.22 and the coefficient of indirect influence of 0.35.
2.
Online Learning
Components Evaluation
In this study, the evaluation was carried out on the components of the
online learning program in improving the competence of vocational school
students in the Regional Education Office of Malang and Batu. The online
learning program in improving the competence of vocational students consists of
several components that are evaluated using the CIPP evaluation model. In this research, the context evaluation
analyzes the needs and supporters needed by students in taking online learning.
The results of this study indicate that the context of the program needs can
run, and students can take part in online learning, namely the components of
learning facilities at home must have facilities including a room or a place to
study at home, furniture to support learning at home, learning aids and
learning resources. In the real condition context of learning facilities shows
the number 0.03, while its effect on improving student competence has a direct
and indirect effect. So that through this context evaluation it is necessary to
get the attention of the components of learning facilities at home to be improved
as a supporting component for the implementation of online learning because it
has a big influence compared to the real situation.
While the context
of parents' attention in learning, in fact, the real condition of the context
of parental attention shows 0.02, so in increasing student competence it is
necessary to increase the attention of parents who have a big influence, either
directly or indirectly. In input evaluation, it can contribute in identifying
and assessing system capabilities, program strategy alternatives, design
procedures for implementation strategies, financing and scheduling. Input
evaluation is included in personal analysis, in this case students related to
online learning programs. The input evaluation component is the initial ability
of the student, the indicators include the value of the subject of ability in
the field of printing graphic design expertise, 2D animation, and creative and
entrepreneurial products that are needed as an evaluation.
Meanwhile, in
process evaluation, which is used to detect or predict a procedure design or
implementation design during the implementation stage, provide information for
program decisions and as a record or archive of procedures that have occurred.
Examining product evaluation on the results of this study is carried out by
defining competence and measuring the criteria for measuring the results that
have been achieved (objectively) through collecting scores from the competency
test, by demonstrating (performing) using both quantitative and qualitative
analysis (Toll & Van Luit, 2013). Student competence
which is the product being evaluated shows that the components of online
learning are very influential. From the analysis of the level of influence of
these components shows the direct effect of parents' attention in learning the
value of gamma (γ) is 0.34, and through learning facilities at home the
value of gamma () is 0.20. The effect size is a measure of the research result
in the form of a size or effect of the influence of another variable. The
effect size is a measure of the magnitude of the effect of a variable on other
variables, the magnitude of the difference and the relationship, which is free
from the influence of the sample size.
This research shows the direct and
indirect influence between variables with different magnitudes with the
following details: First, the learning facilities at home have an effect on
student competence. The effect size of the direct and indirect effect is
between 0.36 - 0.62 and the effect is strong. Every student currently has a
laptop and android as a means of visiting learning. By having a learning tool
in the form of a laptop/android, internet quota facilities are indirectly
available. There are many learning resources available online that are more
varied and interesting, ready to be accessed anytime and anywhere. Through
these things, it shows that learning facilities at home have a strong effect
size.
Second, parents' attention
in learning has an effect on student competence with an effect size and
indirect effect between 0.33 - 0.69 and the effect is strong. Parents are
obliged to guide, supervise, motivate and fulfill children's needs in learning.
This is shown by parents not wanting their children to not take part in
learning which can result in student scores not meeting the minimum completeness
criteria, parents always motivating their children to study hard. And parents
try to meet the needs of their children in learning such as meeting learning
facilities in the form of androids with internet quota.
CONCLUSION
Nowadays online learning has
become a necessity in the world of education as well as online learning
programs in improving vocational competency which play an important role in the
future. This research was conducted to evaluate the effect of the components as
a variable in the online learning program which includes home learning
facilities, and parents' attention in learning to participate in online
learning on student competencies.
The results of the
research and discussion that have been carried out show that learning
facilities at home have a direct effect on student competence. Meanwhile,
parents' attention in learning has a direct effect on student competence. Based
on the explanation above, it shows that the competence of students as a product
is influenced directly and indirectly by the context component of learning
facilities at home and the attention of parents in learning.
Observing the results of
this study, recommendations based on the significance of the results of the
hypothesis and the size of their effect are to improve student competence, it
is necessary to improve learning facilities at home. With the increase in learning
facilities at home, the competence of students will increase. In addition, to
improve student competence, parental attention is needed. With increasing
parental attention, student competence will automatically increase.
REFERENCES
Arikunto, Suharsimi, & Jabar, Cepi Safruddin Abdul.
(2004). Evaluasi program pendidikan pedoman teoritis praktis bagi praktisi
Pendidikan. Jakarta: Bumi Aksara.
Asma, Asma. (2013). Kontribusi Kepala Sekolah Dalam
Peningkatan Profeisonalisme Guru Pendidikan Agama Islam (PAI) di SD Inpres
Kotapulu Kecamatan Dolo Kabupaten Sigi. Universitas Islam Negeri Alauddin
Makassar. Google Scholar
Astuti, Siwi Puji. (2015). Pengaruh kemampuan awal dan minat
belajar terhadap prestasi belajar fisika. Formatif: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan
MIPA, 5(1). Google Scholar
Bafadal, Ibrahim. (2004). Manajemen perlengkapan sekolah
teori dan aplikasinya. Google Scholar
Bandura, Albert. (1977). Social learning theory. Englewood
Cliffs, NJ. Prantice Hall. O‟ Connel, P., Pepler, D., and Craig,
W.(1999). Peer Involvement in Bullying: Insight and Challenges for
Intervention. Journal of Adolescence, 22, 238. Google Scholar
Bimo Walgito, Bimo Walgito. (2004). Pengantar Psikologi
Umum. Andi.
Dalyono, M. (2009). Psikologi Pendidikan dengan Pendekatan
Baru. Jakarta: Rineka Cipta. Google Scholar
Fink, Arlene. (1995). Evaluation for Education and
Psychology. London: Sage Publication. Google Scholar
Gie, Liang. (2004). Cara Belajar yang Baik Bagi Mahasiswa:
Yokyakarta. Gajah Mada Press.
Leonard, Rutman. (1984). Evaluation research methods.
Sage Publishers.
Slameto. (2010). Faktor-Faktor yang Mempengaruhinya
Belajar. Jakarta: PT. Rineka Cipta.
Stufflebeam, Daniel L., & Shinkfield, Anthony J. (2012). Systematic
evaluation: A self-instructional guide to theory and practice (Vol. 8).
Springer Science & Business Media. Google Scholar
Toll, Sylke W. M., & Van Luit, Johannes E. H. (2013). The
development of early numeracy ability in kindergartners with limited working
memory skills. Learning and Individual Differences, 25, 45�54. Google Scholar
Usman, Moh Uzer. (2010). Menjadi Guru Profesional.
Bandung: PT. Remaja Rosdakarya. Google Scholar
Worthen, Blaine R., & Sanders, James R. (1973). Educational
evaluation: Theory and practice. Wadsworth Publishing Company.
|
Ema Sumiarti, Rusijono, Andi Mariono (2021) |
|
First
publication right: |
|
This
article is licensed under: |